WEBSITE UPDATED Tuesday February 21, 2022
Published over a quarter century ago… Many common livewell additives today are chemicals that are not FDA/EPA approved for treating Catch & Live released tournament game fish that people may eat, i.e. “food fish for human consumption.” – tournament caught fish often soak in livewell treated with unknown commercial chemical that are NOT FDA APPROVED FOR USE ON FOOD FISH 8-9 hours during an average fishing tournament day and if they survive after the weigh-in, then released alive back into the wild to be re-caught by tomorrows fishing tournament or by non-tournament anglers the next day and eaten.
Do C&R tournament Directors, tournament anglers and livewell additive manufacturers have any potential moral and/potential legal liability when selling, using and recommending unapproved food fish chemicals for use in boat livewells, tournament holding tanks and tournament live release boat fish tanks?
A published TP&WD Inland Fisheries Opinion… 2002
Mortality Associated with Catch-and-Release Angling: An Annotated Review with Special Emphasis on Livewells and Largemouth Bass by Robert G. Howells
Management Data Series No. 199, 2002
Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, Inland Fisheries Division, 4200 Smith School Road, Austin, Texas 78744
This report should serve as a source-book field manual for fishery professionals who field answers from the angling public about these issues. Pg. i
Drug Approval pgs. 25 & 26 [Livewell Additives and Chemicals]
A wide range of chemicals including anesthetics, antibiotics, biological stains (dyes) and salts are regularly assed to livewells to improve survival of held fishes. Although there is little doubt that these agents do improve the survival of caught and held fishes, most are not legally authorized on for use on food fish.
Example, clove oil, Taylor and Adams (1999) indicated that only one anesthetic (MS-222) was approved for use on food fish, and it had a 21-day withdrawal period before exposed fish could be consumed (carbon dioxide could also be used [as an anesthetic]). Schnick et al. (undated) provided a list of chemicals approved for aquaculture and fish resources management by the EPA and FDA. Their lists indicate that most reagents regularly included in commercial water additives used in tournament angling ARE NOT APPROVED.
Only 1 major reference on live release of BB [Black bass] (Schramm and Heidinger 1988) clearly refused to recommend use of livewell based on FDA restrictions. Other sources continue to boldly advise their use, but they need to consider the potential moral and legal ramifications of those recommendations.
Do you know that the fisherman is always responsible for Osmoregulation and Oxygenation when transporting live fish and live bait in livewells and bait tanks?
Salt or Oxygen, By Adam Johnson
Fighting, handling and holding fish in captivity place severe metabolic demands on brain, muscle, heart, gill and other organ tissues putting them at considerable physiological risk. In general terms we call this stress, but the physiological situation is highly complicated. The degree of stress fish realize, and the potential for subsequent recovery, depends on the type and duration of the physiological stress we place them in and the environment in which they are allowed to recover. To gain a better understanding of fishing-related stress, we must first gain a basic understanding of some of the physiological mechanisms involved.
Energy Metabolism – A Continued Need for Oxygen
The energy used to fuel virtually all cellular functions in every living thing is derived from the compound adenosine triphosphate, or ATP. ATP is needed to make muscles contract, drive brain impulses, allow the heart to beat, provide oxygen uptake by the gills and on an on. ATP is made up of adenosine (A) attached to three phosphate groups (triphosphate – TP). When the cell needs energy the last phosphate bond is broken, and chemical energy is released. The cell converts this chemical energy into the mechanical energy needed to perform the work of the cell.
The by-products remaining after this reaction are adenosine diphosphate (ADP) and inorganic phosphate (Pi). In the cell, ADP and Pi can again recombine through a series of complicated metabolic pathways to re-form ATP, and the energy cycle continues. To biochemists, the metabolic reaction looks like this: ATP ADP + Pi
Most freshwater fish rely heavily on oxygen in their environment. This oxygen is used, primarily, to help fuel the biochemical mechanisms associated with the energy recycling processes. Oxygen-associated energy metabolism is highly efficient and produces the constant supply of energy that fish (or people, for that matter) rely upon to support basically all physiological functions. As long as oxygen and food (fuel) are readily available, the recycling of energy continues unimpeded, and the energy supply meets demand. Energy metabolism using oxygen is called “aerobic” metabolism.
Not all energy production relies on oxygen, however. Cells have developed mechanisms to maintain energy supply during short bursts of sudden, high-intensity exercise, or for short periods when oxygen levels are inadequate (a situation known as hypoxia, or lack of oxygen). Anaerobic or hypoxic energy metabolism is inefficient and cannot be relied on to produce enough energy to keep tissues for very long. To keep a steady balance between energy utilization and supply, fish need oxygen.
Fish must rely on constant supplies of energy. And to get the energy they need; fish also must rely on constant and plentiful supplies of oxygen. Lack of oxygen will quickly deprive fish of the energy they need to sustain life.
Catching Fish Depletes Energy Reserves
Fish can swim continuously for long distances without tiring at a broad range of speeds. This type of swimming, called steady state swimming, is used by fish during normal cruising, or for long distance travel. Muscles that are used in this type of exercise use high volumes of oxygen for energy synthesis. As long as there is a constant supply of oxygen, fish basically never become tired during this type of exercise.
Sudden bursts of high-intensity swimming are called burst swimming. This type of swimming normally lasts for only seconds (possibly minutes) and ends in a physical state of exhaustion. (1,2) Burst swimming is critical when fish attack prey, when they migrate against strong currents or up waterfalls, or when they are fighting after being hooked. This high-intensity exercise totally drains fish of energy reserves. Recovery from such exhaustive exercise may take hours, or sometimes days, depending on the availability of oxygen following the exercise, the duration of the exercise and the degree to which energy compounds are consumed by, or lost from, the fish’s tissue. Energy metabolism during burst swimming is anaerobic, providing only enough energy for a few seconds. If the exercise continues, tissue energy stores will become completely drained. (1)
Think of this in terms of a sprint-type exercise over a 100-yard dash. When you sprint your leg muscles totally consume their energy in only seconds. Short rest between sprints allows the muscle to restore a small amount of energy, but the next sprint is harder and slower. With continued exercise sprinting becomes continually difficult until the muscle is totally exhausted, and you cannot run another step. Muscles become weak and spongy, and if you are not used to the exercise, they will be sore for several days. Only the oxygen you breath after the exercise will allow the energy in your leg muscles to recover, reducing the soreness and regaining muscle strength. Imagine trying to recover if a plastic bag was pulled over your head!
Now relate this example to a fish involving its entire body in an all-consuming sprint-type exercise lasting 30-seconds, two minutes or longer. Energy from the whole body is recruited and used up. Even in a well-oxygenated environment, like a trout stream, the fish will need to find a quiet place to rest for several hours before it regains its energy. Imagine this fish placed in a livewell with little or no oxygen. Energy cannot recover and the fish will either die or become so energy starved it will likely die later. It is not the lack of oxygen that kills the fish. It is the lack of energy and the inability to recover lost energy stores.
Factors Affecting Recovery
Associated with the depletion of energy reserves during burst swimming is an increase in tissue (including blood) lactic acid (or lactate). As an acid, lactate produces hydrogen ions that lower the pH of the tissue, ultimately reducing the total energy supply of the cell. (1,3) It also drains the cell of important metabolites it needs to recover. Once these metabolites are exhausted, the fish will not be able to perform another burst of exercise until they are replenished. Clearance of lactic acid, and restoration of normal cellular function, can take anywhere from four to 12 hours. Over this time the fish is able to restore lost metabolites, but 12-hours still may not be sufficiently long to allow cellular energy levels to rebound. Factors such as body size, water temperature, water hardness, water pH and oxygen availability all play a part in time to recovery.
The following is a list summarizing the effects of certain factors on the physiology and recovery from exhaustive exercise in fish:
– Body size: There is a positive correlation between anaerobic energy metabolism and power requirements of burst exercise in the rainbow trout. In general, bigger fish require more relative energy to perform burst swimming exercise. This creates a larger drain on energy reserves, taking longer to recover.(4)
– Environmental temperature: Clearance rate of lactic acid and energy-draining metabolites are significantly affected by acclimation to temperature. Large changes in ambient temperature dramatically effect the fish’s ability to recover. (5) Dramatic heating or cooling of the environment will reduce recovery rate.
Water hardness: A reduction in the hardness of environmental water has a minimal, but important, effect on the metabolic and acid-base status of the blood. (3) Much of the work describing this effect has been conducted in saltwater species, so it is not fully known if the results are directly transferable to freshwater fish. What is known, however, is that when freshwater fish are stressed, water flows across cell membranes (particularly those of the gills) and the blood becomes diluted. This dilution puts additional pressure on maintaining salt balance in the fish. Maintaining salt balance is called osmoregulation and it will be described in more detail later.
– Water pH: Moderate water acidity will help fish recover more quickly. Higher water pH will slow the recovery process dramatically. (3)
Why are these things important? Stress associated with catch and release can contribute to catch related mortality. The lessons learned from studies investigating the effects of, and recovery from, exhaustive exercise have the potential to decrease the number of stress-related deaths and increase fish productivity. Understanding the energy metabolism of fish, and the factors that affect energy metabolism, are critical to understanding how fish must be handled and treated when caught.
Osmoregulation – Maintaining Salt Balance in Stressed Fish
The regulation of salt (ion) balance is fundamental to all life. The structure and function of cells depend closely on their interactions with water and things that are dissolved in water, and few factors affect the viability of an organism as extensively as osmoregulation. Thus, fish invest considerable energy in controlling the composition of intracellular and extracellular fluids. In fish, osmoregulation typically consumes 25% – 50% of the total metabolic energy output, possibly the largest energy consumer in the animal.(6,7,8)
The mechanisms used by fish to maintain salt balance are highly complicated and extremely energy dependent. Since anaerobic energy metabolism is less than 1/10 as efficient as energy metabolism in an oxygen rich environment, the energy demand of tissue osmoregulation cannot be met by anaerobic energy metabolism alone. A rapid fall in cellular ATP levels causes a slow-down, and eventual stop, in the cellular pumps used to control the movement of salts across the cell membrane. A disruption ion pump activity causes the cell to lose ion homeostasis, and ions are then free to run down their concentration gradients putting the survival of the cell – and the fish – at risk.
Both fresh- and saltwater fish are constantly faced with the challenge of ionic and osmotic regulation. Freshwater fish, in which tissue ion concentrations are much greater than the water in their surrounding environment, must deal with osmotic water uptake and loss of ions through permeable epithelial tissues and via the urine. The opposite is obviously true in saltwater fish. Freshwater fish produce copious amounts of highly dilute urine. In fact, they will produce urine weighing up to 20% of their body weight every day. Imagine a 200-pound man generating 40-pounds – or about five gallons – of urine every day! While fish kidneys are highly efficient at removing water from the fish, they are equally efficient at keeping body salts out of the urine. This mechanism allows the salts to stay in the body, helping to control salt balance. While very small amounts of salt are passed in the urine, most osmoregulation is managed by cells in the fish’s gills.
Sodium is the primary ion found in tissue. Transport of sodium across cell membranes is highly energy dependent and is facilitated by an enzyme called Na/K-ATPase. This enzyme resides right inside the cell membrane and uses the energy supplied by ATP to move sodium in one direction across the cell membrane, while its counter-ion (potassium or whatever) moves in the other direction. This process allows muscles to contract, it provides the electrochemical gradient needed to stimulate the heartbeat and allows all manner of brain and nerve signals to be transmitted. (9,10)
Imagine yourself to be a Na/K ATPase enzyme in line in a fast-food restaurant. You hand your money to the attendant, pick up your change, and then grab your number three value meal. The same is true in the fish’s cell. A sodium ion is handed across the cell membrane, a second (different) ion is picked up, and this ion is brought back into the cell.
Most osmoregulation occurs in the fish’s gill. The enzyme Na/K-ATPase is primarily responsible for maintaining salt balance and it resides in the membrane of the fish gill cell. There is one pump on the side of the gill cell next to the blood, and another in the membrane on the side next to the water. In freshwater fish, the system of osmoregulation works like this…
Ammonia is produced as a waste product of fish metabolism. When fish exercise, they produce a great deal of ammonia, and that ammonia has to be excreted from the blood. Unlike higher animals, fish do not excrete ammonia in the urine. Instead, ammonia (and most all other nitrogen waste) diffuses through the gill membrane. About 80% – 90% of the nitrogenous waste of fish metabolism are excreted via the gills.
Ammonia from the blood is exchanged across the gill cell membrane for sodium. This removes the ammonia from the blood and increases the ammonia concentration in the gill cell. In turn, a sodium ion is passed from the gill cell and into the blood. The plasma sodium concentration is increased and the sodium concentration in the gill cell goes down. To replace the sodium ion in the gill cell and restore its salt balance the cell then passes the ammonia out of the gill cell into the environment and exchanges it for another sodium ion from the water.
In like fashion, chloride ions from the water are exchanged for bicarbonate. Bicarbonate is formed when CO2 from cellular respiration combines with water in the cell. Remember, like us, fish use oxygen in respiration. The byproducts of respiration are CO2 and water. We get rid of CO2 by simply exhaling, but obviously fish can’t do that. Instead, the CO2 formed in fish respiration combines with water in the cell to form bicarbonate ion. Chloride ions move into the cell and bicarbonate moves out of the cell and into the environment. (11) Hydrogen ions can also be exchanged for sodium in this manner, helping to control blood pH. For a graphic depiction of all this refer to Figure 1.
Figure 1: Diagram of the model of ion transport in the fish gill
(Modified after several authors)
These two mechanisms for ion exchange are called absorption and secretion and occur within two cell types of the fish gill known as respiratory cells and chloride cells. Given that chloride cells are used to eliminate salts, they are larger and more highly developed in saltwater species and not well established in freshwater species. Respiratory cells, which are involved in gas exchange, nitrogenous waste removal and acid-base balance, are more developed in freshwater fish. They are supplied by arterial flow and are used to exchange sodium and chloride for ammonia and bicarbonate, respectively.
Again, the most important point to remember is that the exchange of ions that takes place in these cells is highly dependent on energy availability. If there is not enough energy to drive the ion pumps, these exchanges cannot occur and water will flood the cells by diffusion, killing the fish. Maintaining control of salt and water balance is vital and requires considerable metabolic energy to power it. Energy is the key constituent.
Consequences of Oxygen Starvation on Osmoregulation
After only a few minutes of oxygen starvation the membrane surrounding brain cells loses it ability to control ion balance causing a release of chemicals (called neurotransmitters) that speed up calcium influx into the cell. The increased level of calcium in the cells triggers a number of degenerative processes that can lead to neurological damage or death. These processes involve the destruction of DNA, important cellular proteins, and even the cell membrane itself. Free radicals and nitric oxide are also formed, eating away further at the cell membrane and attacking intracellular constituents. (12,13) The important events of this catastrophe are common to most vertebrate brains, including both fish and humans. Similar events occur in other tissues, like liver (14-16), muscle (7), blood cells (17) and heart (9). Once calcium has invaded the cells it takes much more energy to remove it, via the ATP-dependent calcium pumps.
Another consequence of oxygen starvation (or hypoxia) is the release of hormones from the pituitary gland. Prolactin is the most prevalent of these hormones in most fish species, both fresh- and saltwater. The release of this hormone affects the permeability of cell membranes in the gill, skin, kidney, intestine and urinary bladder and impacts ion transport mechanisms. Prolactin release helps regulate water-ion balance by decreasing water uptake and promoting retention of important ions (especially Na+ and Cl-). In doing so, prolactin helps to maintain the salt balance of the blood and tissues and keeps the fish from swelling with water. (11)
The main threat to freshwater fish is the loss of ions by diffusion into the external environment rather than the elimination of excess water. Even though the regulation of water balance may be important, it is secondary to the importance of ion retention. However, the effect of prolactin on water permeability should not be dismissed as inconsequential. Prolactin decreases the osmotic permeability of the gills, retaining ions and excluding water. It also increases gill mucous secretion, contributing to ion-water balance by impeding the passage of molecules across the membrane.
Salt or Oxygen?
So, which is more important, salt or oxygen? The answer is clear. In fish that have been stressed by sudden bursts of high-intensity exercise – like fighting at the end of a line – energy deprivation is the most vital concern. Tissues become almost totally depleted of energy, and it takes several hours (or perhaps days) for them to recover. Anaerobic energy metabolism cannot keep pace with cellular demand and large amounts of oxygen are needed to drive the pathways of energy recovery in the cell. Oxygen deprivation will not allow these pathways to function efficiently, if at all. And the result is dead fish. They might not die right away, but they will die. Salt balance, no matter how much salt there is in the livewell environment, cannot be maintained without large amounts energy to fuel the process. And while the importance of maintaining ion balance cannot be over emphasized, the first consideration must be providing stressed fish the energy they need to turn on the osmoregulatory processes.
How Much Oxygen is Enough?
Oxygen, not water temperature or salt level, is the main culprit in fish death in the livewell or in catch-related stress. However, livewell water temperature is a main determinant of how much oxygen can be made available to fish and how quickly they will utilize what’s available.
The maximum amount of dissolved oxygen in water is called its saturation level. Saturation level decrease as the temperature of the water increases. For example, at 70 degrees, water saturates at 8.9 parts per million (ppm). At 80 degrees, saturation is achieved at 8.0 ppm, and at 90 degrees only 7.3 ppm. At higher temperatures, fish metabolism also increases, and they use oxygen faster. Therefore, at 80-degrees, oxygen concentrations below 5.0 ppm may prove quickly fatal.
Here is an example used by Hal Schramm, noted fisheries biologist, that will put this temperature/metabolism/oxygen relationship into perspective. Ten pounds of bass in a 15-gallon livewell will reduce the oxygen concentration from 75% saturation to stress levels in about eight minutes at 60 degrees; in seven minutes at 70 degrees; and in only 2.5 minutes at 85 degrees. (18)
Standard livewell aeration systems simply cannot keep up with this oxygen demand. A recirculating aeration system will raise the oxygen level in a 15-gallon livewell from 3 ppm to 7 ppm in about eight minutes when the water is 60 degrees. It will take about 14 minutes at 70 degrees. At 85 degrees, a standard livewell system simply cannot get to 7 ppm. With several fish in the livewell, a standard livewell system is not able to keep the oxygen level above stressful limits that may prove fatal or will certainly create stress on the fish that may not be recoverable – almost certainly leading to delayed fish mortality.
Decreasing the water temperature with ice is one solution but remember that too great a change in water temperature adds its own element of stress. Large changes in water temperature affect lactic acid clearance and slow metabolic recovery. In addition, to lower the water temperature by five degrees for a full tournament day in temperatures above 85 degrees could require up to 50-pounds of ice! Relying on ice to sufficiently cool a livewell to fully oxygenate the water is unrealistic.
*Supplemental oxygen is required, along with temperature control of the livewell, to supply fish the oxygen they need to recover from metabolic stress and promote osmoregulation. There are no two ways about it; oxygen delivery is the key to helping fish overcome the stress that comes with angling and survival in the livewell.
1. Milligan CL. Metabolic recovery from exhaustive exercise in rainbow trout: Review. Comp Biochem Physiol, 1996; 113A:51-60.
2. Moyes CD, TG West. Exercise metabolism in fish. In: Biochemistry and Molecular Biology of Fishes, Volume 4 (Eds. Hochachka and Mommsen). Elsevier Science, 1995, Boston.
3. Rossiter AM. Physiology and survival of Atlantic salmon following exhaustive exercise in soft and acidic water: implications for the catch and release fishery. M.Sc. Thesis. 1996. Queen’s University, Kingston, Canada. 86pp.
4. Ferguson RA, JD Kieffer, BL Tufts. The effects of body size on the acid-base and metabolic status in the white muscle of rainbow trout before and after exhaustive exercise. J Exp Biol, 1993; 180:195-207.
5. Kiefer JD, S Currie, BL Tufts. Effects of environmental temperature on the metabolic and acid-base responses on rainbow trout to exhaustive exercise. J Exp Biol, 1994; 194:299-317.
6. Grau EG. Environmental physiology and comparative endocrinology of estuarine fish. Available on-line www2.hawaii.edu/zoology/graduate/faculty/grau.htm.
7. Laiz-Carrion R, S Sangiao-Alvarellos, JM Guzman, MP Martin, JM Miguez, JL Soengas, JM Mancera. Energy metabolism in fish tissues relaed to osmoregulation and cortisol action: Fish growth and metabolism. Environmental, nutritional and hormonal regulation. Fish Physiol and Biochem, 2002; 27(3-4):179-188.
8. Morgan JD, GK Iwama. Energy cost of NaCl transport in isolated gills of cutthroat trout. Am J Physiol, 1999; 277(3 Pt 2):R631-639.
9. MacCormack TJ, WR Driedzic. Mitochondrial ATP-sensitive K+ channels influence force development and anoxic contractility in a flatfish, yellowtail flounder Limanda ferruginea, but not Atlantic cod Gadus morhua heart. J Exp Biol, 2002; 205:1411-1418.
10. Slagle R. Gill Na,K-ATPase and osmoregulation in the sailfin molly, Poecilia latipinna. Honor’s Thesis, 1986. Lafayette College, Easton, Pa.
11. Manzon LA. The role of prolactin in fish osmoregulation: a review. Gen Compar Endocrin, 2002; 125:291-310.
12. Nilsson GE, M Perez-Pinzon, K Dimberg, S Winberg. Brain sensitivity to anoxia in fish as reflected by changes in extracellular potassium-ion activity. Am J Physiol, 1993; 264:R250-R253.
13. Hylland P, GE Nilsson, D Johansson. Anoxic brain failure in an ectothermic vertebrate: release of amino acids and K+ in rainbow trout thalamus. Am J Physiol, 1995; 269:R1077-R1084.
14. Krumschnabel G, PJ Schwarzbaum, J Lisch, C Biasi, W Weiser. Oxygen-dependent energetics of anoxia-intolerant hepatocytes. J Mol Biol, 2000; 203(Pt 5):951-959.
15. Krumschnabel G, C Biasi, W Weiser. Action of adenosine on energetics, protein synthesis and K(+) homeostasis in teleost hepatocytes. J Exp Biol, 2000; 203(Pt 27):2657-2665.
16. Krumschnabel G, C Manzl, PJ Schwartzbaum. Importance of glycolysis for the energetics of anoxia-tolerant and anoxia-intolerant teleost hepatocytes. Physiol Biochem Zool, 2001; 74(3):413-419.
17. Pesquero J, T Roig, J Bermudez, J Sanchez. Energy metabolism by trout red blood cells: substrate utilization. J Exp Biol, 1994; 193:183-190.
18. Schramm H. Surviving the summer. Guest article, Bassmaster online. Available at espn.go.com/outdoors/bassmaster/s/bass_biology_surviving_summer.html.
Oxygen systems that deliver pure oxygen must deliver enough pure oxygen continuously to quickly reverse the cellular oxygen debt and meet the cellular demand for the total biomass of live bait or all the fish in the livewell being transported. Any oxygen system that delivers a fixed or limited flow and concentration of oxygen may deliver less oxygen than a standard livewell aerator or water pump which is often deadly every summer. Know and understand the limitations of any pure oxygen system, it’s vitally important. Without enough oxygen supplied continuously during transport, all the aeration, salt, chemicals, ice and any other lifesaving efforts will fail.
OPINION: FLW Tour, Tournament Director Bill Taylor said anglers should be conscientious about which additives they use. Some of them have ingredients not yet approved by the Federal Drug and Food Administration, he said, and some have warnings on the package stating that the chemical could be harmful to humans if consumed. Though all FLW Outdoors tournaments and many others follow the catch-and-release format, it is entirely possible that any fish released by an angler could eventually be caught and consumed by another fisherman.
Taylor said he has spoken to many fisheries biologists in different parts of the country about the use of chemical additives. They recommend not using any additive that could contaminate a fish and harm either the body of water’s fish population or humans who might catch and eat the fish. Although FLW Outdoors has seen some success with a few of the additives it has used, Taylor said he is not convinced that all of them are effective.
“I’m not so sure that any of those additives are of real great benefit,” he said, adding that a common and safe compound found in most households has probably been the most effective additive. “With biologists, they say just regular block salt added into your livewell can be the best additive.”
Non-iodized salt added to a livewell in the right proportion, roughly 1/3 cup for every five gallons of water, can help reduce fish stress and maintain electrolyte balances. Some sources suggest that adding salt can also help reduce the risk of a fish becoming infected. http://www.flwoutdoors.com/fishing-articles/tech-tackle-reviews/140793/livewells-part-3/
We thank Adam Johnson for permission to reprint this article.